Blue Book Nights
Painting: a chrome saucer stands in a farmyard among birches and log buildings on a bright spring day.

Eagle River, WisconsinApril 18, 1961

Eagle River, 1961

Case 04 · the filmThe Air Force Tested a Plumber's Pancake in 1961 - Saucer Men Cooked It

On April 18, 1961, Joe Simonton, a plumber in the north woods of Wisconsin, said a craft came down in his back yard and that he was handed four warm pancakes through its hatch.

Most stories like this end with the telling. This one left a 98-page Project Blue Book file. Two deputies inspected a pancake. The astronomer J. Allen Hynek came up from Northwestern University. A radar squadron drew the yard to scale. A piece of one pancake went to a laboratory at Wright-Patterson, where a lab sheet dated May 10, 1961 lists what it was made of.

The word on the Air Force’s record card for the case is “hallucination”. The film goes through the papers one by one and shows where they do not agree with each other.

Five minutes

The morning of April 18, 1961, as Joe Simonton told it. Twenty paintings from the film, in the order he gave. Skip to the file

  1. Painting: Joe Simonton scatters grain to his chickens by the coop.

    He was sixty and lived out there alone, with the chickens.

  2. Painting: Joe at the kitchen table by the window, eating breakfast.

    That Tuesday, he was in the kitchen having a late breakfast.

  3. Painting: through the kitchen window, a chrome saucer hangs low over the yard.

    He looked out the kitchen window and saw a huge saucer lowering.

  4. Painting: the chrome craft on the driveway, Joe standing beside it.

    About thirty feet across, shaped like two soup bowls.

  5. Painting: an open hatch in the chrome rim of the craft.

    A hatch opened upward from the rim, like a car trunk lid.

  6. Painting: a man in a black knit cap leans out of the hatch.

    The one in the hatch wore a knit cap and a turtleneck.

  7. Painting: the dark inside of the craft, a man seated at a panel.

    Inside, everything was black, the color of wrought iron.

  8. Painting: the man in the hatch holds out a metal jug.

    The man in the hatch held out a jug.

  9. Painting: Joe holds the bright metal jug in both hands.

    A beautiful thing, Joe said.

  10. Painting: seen from the hatch, the man lifts a cupped hand to his mouth. Joe stands below with the jug.

    The man made motions like drinking. Nobody said a word.

  11. Painting: Joe fills the jug at an iron hand pump in the basement.

    Joe took the jug down to the pump in his basement.

  12. Painting: Joe on his toes, one hand on the craft, lifting the jug to the hatch.

    To hand it up, he had to go up on his toes.

  13. Painting: a man in black stands at a low grill inside the craft.

    He could see the third man, standing at a low grill.

  14. Painting: a hand turns small cakes on a flat grill.

    He was turning cakes, or something like cakes. There was no flame.

  15. Painting: four thin pancakes, full of small holes, on an open palm.

    Four of them. Thin, full of tiny holes, and warm.

  16. Painting: Joe salutes the craft, and the man in the hatch salutes back.

    The man gave him a salute, and Joe saluted back.

  17. Painting: from below, a hand pulls the hatch closed.

    Then the man reached up and pulled the hatch closed by hand.

  18. Painting: the craft high over the pines, Joe watching from the yard.

    The ship lifted, went south, and was gone.

  19. Painting: Joe stands alone in the empty yard, looking at his hand.

    Then it was quiet, and Joe stood there alone with four pancakes.

  20. Painting: a plate with four pancakes, one with a bite missing, beside a cup of coffee.

    Later he said they tasted like cardboard.

Watch the film

What the film rests on

The sources the script was checked against.

  • Project Blue Book case file “Eagle River, Wisconsin, 18 Apr 61”, 98 pages: record card, deputies’ report, Hynek’s report of investigation, the radar squadron’s report with the yard drawn to scale, the laboratory sheet for sample 7003, the letters to and from the Food and Drug Administration, the summary of June 2, 1961.National Archives file, read online · archive.org
  • Jacques Vallée, Passport to Magonia (1969), on Simonton and the old stories of food taken from the fairies.Book
  • Dayton Daily News, May 18, 2023, on the pieces of pancake held in storage by the National Museum of the U.S. Air Force.Newspaper

The paper trail

Pages of the Project Blue Book file and Air Force photographs of the yard. Open a sheet to read it.

U.S. Air Force, National Archives · public domain

Full list: what is real on screen, and what was re-set

Real material

  • Pages of the Project Blue Book file, including the record card, the laboratory sheet and the Air Force lettersU.S. Air Force, National Archives · public domain
  • Photographs of the Simonton yard taken on April 26, 1961, from the same fileU.S. Air Force · public domain
  • Simonton’s sketch of the craft, from the same fileProject Blue Book file
  • Vilas County Courthouse, photograph of 2017TheCatalyst31, Wikimedia Commons · CC0

Photographs under a Creative Commons licence are also credited on screen where they appear.

Re-set or drawn for the film

  • The Associated Press headline of April 23, 1961 is re-set in type for the film.
  • The scale plan of the yard from the file is redrawn for the film.
  • The maps of Wisconsin, the Great Lakes and the United States are drawn for the film.

The illustrations are paintings made for this video, and the narration is a synthetic voice.

Corrections: none filed for this case so far. How corrections work

Sample 7003 took a 98-page file to tell. If this one was worth a coffee to you, it helps me open the next file.

Support the next case file