Newark Valley, New YorkApril 24, 1964
Newark Valley, 1964
Case 03 · the filmA Farmer Met Two Martians in 1964 - They Named the Astronauts Who Would Die
At ten in the morning on April 24, 1964, Gary Wilcox, a dairy farmer in Newark Valley, New York, drove up his hill to check on an old refrigerator. He said two small men came out from under something else and talked with him for close to two hours.
A week later he gave a signed statement at the sheriff’s office in Owego. A neighbor, Priscilla Baldwin, who had served three years in Air Force radar, had already written down her questions and his answers. A deputy walked the field with her and noted what he found there. On May 7 the Binghamton Press ran the story as “Martian ‘Visit’ Stirs Tioga”.
The film is told from those papers and from the psychiatrist Berthold Schwarz, who sat down with Wilcox on October 18, 1968. It spends most of its time on one question: when, exactly, the names of the astronauts were first written down.
One morning in April
April 24, 1964, on Gary Wilcox's hill, as he told it in his signed statement. Twenty-one paintings from the film, in order. Skip to the file

Davis Hollow Road, a few miles outside Newark Valley.

April 24, 1964. Gary Wilcox was spreading manure.

He looked up at the hill and saw something shiny on top.

At first he took it for an old refrigerator.

A little bigger than a car, smooth and shiny.

He thumped it, and he kicked it.

Two small men came out from under it.

No nose, no mouth, no hair.

Alfalfa with the roots and soil still on.

They talked. He could not tell you if it was English.

He thought it was Candid Camera.

They didn't seem to know what a cow was.

The lime didn't interest them.

They seemed to know a great deal about planets and air.

It glided off slowly over the valley.

Then he went back to the milking.

His bag of fertilizer stayed up on the hill.

Then some friends. For a few days that was all.

Priscilla Baldwin came to the door. Her field was radar.

She wrote his answers down, almost like a deposition.

She asked Gary to take her up to the spot.
Watch the film
What the film rests on
The sources the script was checked against.
- Berthold E. Schwarz, interview with Gary Wilcox of October 18, 1968, printed with the statement, the neighbor’s notes and the deputy’s report in Flying Saucer Review (1969).Journal; the film quotes the statement, the notes and the report as Schwarz printed them. I have not found scans of the originals. · archive.org
- Binghamton Press, May 7 and May 9, 1964. The May 9 report is reprinted in Flying Saucer Review, vol. 10 no. 5 (September to October 1964), “Down on the Farm”, pp. 22-23.Newspaper and journal reprint
- Olga Hotchkiss in Fate, September 1964, as retold in Flying Saucer Review (1967).Magazine, through a later retelling
- Peter Gilman, “Do the Cherubim Come from Mars? A preliminary study based on the Gary Wilcox Contact Story”, Flying Saucer Review (1967).Journal
- Jacques Vallée, Passport to Magonia (1969), chapter “The Good People”.Book
- Jerome Clark, Extraordinary Encounters (ABC-CLIO, 2000).Reference book
The paper trail
No original pages are online for this case. These are the sheets as set for the film from the texts I worked from, and the NASA photographs in it. Open a sheet to read it.
Priscilla Baldwin's questions and answersSet for the film from her notes as later quoted. Not her handwriting.
The deputy's reportSet for the film from its quoted text: one set of tractor tracks.
“Martian ‘Visit’ Stirs Tioga”The Binghamton Press, May 7, 1964, headline set for the film.
A column of May 9, 1964Set for the film from the newspaper text.
A question and answer page, 1969Set for the film from the magazine text.
The Mercury SevenNASA photograph, public domain.
Gus Grissom, 1961NASA photograph, public domain.
The Apollo 1 plaque at Launch Complex 34Photograph: Bubba73, public domain.
Sheets set in type for the film from quoted texts, not originals · NASA photographs, public domain · plaque photograph: Bubba73, public domain
Full list: what is real on screen, and what was re-set
Real material
- John Glenn boarding Friendship 7, 1962; Virgil Grissom in his Mercury suit, 1961; Gemini-Titan on the pad; the Apollo 1 capsule after the fire, 1967; Glenn in 1998NASA · public domain
- Memorial plaque at Launch Complex 34Bubba73, Wikimedia Commons · public domain
Photographs under a Creative Commons licence are also credited on screen where they appear.
Re-set or drawn for the film
- Wilcox’s statement, the deputy’s report and the two newspaper items are re-set in type for the film from the published wording. No scans of the originals were available.
- The neighbor’s notes are shown in handwriting made for the film.
- The maps of Newark Valley and the road to the farm are drawn for the film.
The illustrations are paintings made for this video, and the narration is a synthetic voice.
Corrections: none filed for this case so far. How corrections work
This case came down to one envelope and a date. If it was worth a coffee to you, it helps me find the next one.
Support the next case file