Blue Book Nights
Painting: an old pickup with its headlights on in a night field, a red glow behind the tree on the hill.

Flatwoods, West VirginiaSeptember 12, 1952

Flatwoods, 1952

Case 01 · the filmThe 10-Foot Flatwoods Monster: What Really Landed in 1952

On the evening of Friday, September 12, 1952, a light crossed the sky over central West Virginia. In Flatwoods, Kathleen May, Gene Lemon, a seventeen-year-old National Guardsman, and a group of local boys climbed a hill to see where it had come down. They came back frightened.

That same night a newspaperman, Lee Stewart of the Braxton Democrat, walked one of them back up the hill. Within days the United Press had his account on the wire, and a New York artist had drawn the figure from the witnesses’ descriptions.

The only page the Air Force kept on that night is a typed sheet headed “Fireball”. The film follows how the story grew in print, gives the best ordinary answer, the one Joe Nickell worked out on the ground in 2000, and then goes back to what that answer leaves out.

One hill, one Friday

The evening of September 12, 1952, as the people on the hill told it, and what came after. Twenty-two paintings from the film, in order. Skip to the file

  1. Painting: the main street of Flatwoods at dusk, a store porch lit, cars parked out front.

    Flatwoods. A hot Friday in September, 1952.

  2. Painting: a farmer by his chickens looks up as a green fireball crosses the evening sky.

    At about seven, something crossed the sky in the east.

  3. Painting: a football in the grass of a school field at sundown, the schoolhouse behind.

    Some boys were out by the schoolhouse, with a football.

  4. Painting: a small red light low over a dark valley at dusk.

    A light came around a hill and crossed the valley, slowly.

  5. Painting: a man on a porch watches a long red light with sparks trailing behind it.

    Red balls of fire shooting out behind, one man said.

  6. Painting: a woman stands in a lit doorway, a red glow over the hills beyond.

    Kathleen May came to the door. She was thirty-two.

  7. Painting: a flashlight beam in the grass beside a hound dog at dusk.

    Gene Lemon got a flashlight and brought his dog.

  8. Painting: a flashlight on an old wooden gate held shut with a chain.

    A gate shut with a chain and a twist of heavy wire.

  9. Painting: fence posts on a hill at night, a red glow beyond the crest.

    Below the crest, something lay on the slope, pulsing.

  10. Painting: a flashlight beam cuts through low mist in the tall grass.

    Then they were in it, and the smell was overpowering.

  11. Painting: a pulsing red light low in the grass of the hillside.

    The light lay in the grass, dim, then bright.

  12. Painting: two small lights in the dark branches of a big tree.

    Up on a limb, two small lights. An animal, he thought.

  13. Painting: a tall hooded figure in the dark woods, two beams of light from its eyes.

    Two lights where eyes would be, throwing beams over their heads.

  14. Painting: an ace of spades lying in the grass under a flashlight.

    A dark hood around the face, like the ace of spades.

  15. Painting: the tall dark figure in the mist, red light behind it.

    The boys told Sanderson it had no arms at all.

  16. Painting: a dog lies low under a porch in the dark, light through the boards.

    Back at the house, the dog was under the porch, trembling.

  17. Painting: a man's hand pressed into the grass of the hillside at night.

    Close to the ground, the smell was still there.

  18. Painting: two long tracks pressed into the tall grass of the hill in the morning.

    Next morning, two tracks in the grass, like skid marks.

  19. Painting: an artist's hand drawing on a sheet at a drafting table.

    In New York, an artist drew the face from their words.

  20. Painting: an old television set showing a pale figure.

    It went on the air, to a background of weird music.

  21. Painting: a round patch of flattened grass on the hillside in morning light.

    Sanderson found a circle in the grass, still flattened.

  22. Painting: a big tree on a quiet hilltop above the valley at night.

    The hill is still there, above Flatwoods.

Watch the film

What the film rests on

The sources the script was checked against.

  • United Press, “The Monster of Braxton County: Around a Bend They Saw a Pair of Bulging Eyes”, Washington Daily News, September 15, 1952.Newspaper
  • Charleston Daily Mail, September 1952, “Braxton Co. Residents Faint, Become Ill After Run-In With Weird 10-Foot Monster”.Newspaper
  • Charleston Gazette, September 23, 1952, photograph and caption: May and Lemon with the drawing.Newspaper
  • Evening Star (Washington, D.C.), September 13, 1952, p. 22, on the fireball seen in four states.Newspaper
  • Project Blue Book file “Flatwoods, West Virginia”, two pages, with the typed sheet headed “Fireball”.National Archives
  • Gray Barker, “The Monster and the Saucer”, Fate, January 1953, and They Knew Too Much About Flying Saucers (1956).Magazine and book · archive.org
  • Ivan T. Sanderson, Uninvited Visitors (1967), on his visit of September 18, 1952 and his interviews with the boys.Book
  • Civilian Saucer Investigation (Los Angeles), Bulletin no. 2, winter 1953, “More On The Green Monster”.Bulletin · project1947.com
  • Joe Nickell, “The Flatwoods UFO Monster”, Skeptical Inquirer, vol. 24 no. 6, November to December 2000.Magazine · skepticalinquirer.org

The paper trail

The Air Force pages, the newspapers of that week and the map. Open a sheet to read it.

Air Force pages: National Archives, public domain · newspapers as printed in 1952 · map: U.S. Geological Survey, public domain · owl photograph as credited

Full list: what is real on screen, and what was re-set

Real material

  • Both pages of the Project Blue Book file on FlatwoodsU.S. Air Force, National Archives · public domain
  • USGS topographic maps: Sutton, 1:24,000 (1967); Charleston (1954 and 1957) and Clarksburg (1956), 1:250,000U.S. Geological Survey · public domain
  • Newspaper pages and the Gazette photograph of September 1952Charleston Daily Mail; United Press in the Washington Daily News; Charleston Gazette
  • The original 1952 colored pencil drawing of the figureNew York artist, name not established
  • Barn owl photographsAlias 0591, john.purvis and caroline legg · CC BY 2.0; Jens Oldenburg · CC BY 4.0; Dannymoore1973 · CC0; all from Wikimedia Commons · Files: Alias 0591, john.purvis, caroline legg, Jens Oldenburg, Dannymoore1973

Photographs under a Creative Commons licence are also credited on screen where they appear.

Re-set or drawn for the film

  • The path of the fireball and the diagrams of the hill are drawn for the film.

The illustrations are paintings made for this video, and the narration is a synthetic voice.

Corrections: none filed for this case so far. How corrections work

This was the first case on the channel. If it was worth a coffee to you, it helps me make the next one.

Support the next case file